Choosing the right innovation vehicle — between collaborations with startups, Corporate Venture Capital, intrapreneurship, or M&A — is not trivial and requires a thoughtful approach for companies seeking to accelerate their transformation and remain competitive. Here are some concrete ways to maximize the impact of your open innovation initiatives, from defining needs to industrializing projects, including managing cultural differences.
1. The strategic choice of the innovation vehicle: how to maximize the impact?
It is essential to understand that there is no one-size-fits-all solution when it comes to innovation. The key is to choose the right innovation vehicle for each strategic objective: is it to accelerate product innovation, to transform business models, or to increase organizational agility? A company can use external innovation (collaborations, M&A, CVC) to complement internal innovation. It is essential to set up a clear governance framework to assess the expected ROI and adjust the trajectory according to the results obtained.
2. The importance of a clearly defined need: why the solution takes precedence over the partner
In many cases, businesses focus on choosing the partner (startup, scale-up, research center, etc.) without a thorough understanding of the problem at hand. To successfully collaborate in open innovation, it is crucial to articulate a specific need and to assess the various solutions that could meet it. Sometimes this leads to unexpected partnerships with non-traditional players who have complementary technology or know-how.
3. The ROI of innovation: reconciling divergent goals
Innovation programs should be aligned with the organization's strategic priorities and ROI goals. This may involve choosing between different forms of ROI: financial, industrial, marketing, or HR. A corporate venture capital (CVC) fund can be oriented primarily towards an industrial or commercial goal with long-term financial returns or more marketing and reputation. Understanding these choices and assuming them is essential to maximize the impact of each initiative.
4. The cultural challenges of open innovation: how to create an environment conducive to collaboration?
Cultural differences between startups, large companies, and research centers can be a barrier to open innovation. To overcome these obstacles, it is necessary to create an environment where risk-taking is encouraged and working methods are adapted to harmonize the agility of startups with the structure of large companies. This cultural change can take place through training, co-creation workshops, or even through intrapreneurship, and disseminated within all departments of the organization. Change is everyone's business.
5. The industrialization of PoCs: from experimentation to scale
Too often, open innovation initiatives stop after a successful Proof of Concept (PoC), without succeeding in moving to large-scale adoption. To take this step, businesses and technology partners need to invest in standardizing processes, managing change, and adapting solutions for different markets. Success is based on rigorous industrialization planning, including market testing, technological integration and stakeholder engagement.
In short
Whatever your responsibility and direction within your organization - Strategy, Innovation, R&D or R&I, Tech & Digital, Business Unit, CSR, Purchasing, M&A, CVC, etc. - integrate strategic thinking on the alignment of innovation objectives transversely with all stakeholders:
- Choose the right “innovation vehicle”: adapt your strategy according to the goals to be achieved, whether they are internal innovation, external collaboration, or growth through acquisition.
- Focus on finding solutions before choosing a partner: identify the problem to be solved before selecting the type of partner, which opens the door to diverse collaborations. To do this, do not hesitate to study the market, perform a benchmark and Mapping of solutions.
- Assume your choices to optimize ROI: clarify priorities in terms of return on investment and adapt your innovation initiatives accordingly, for example, by distinguishing financial goals from marketing goals.
.jpg)
